19th-Century Majors
New York Mutuals
Active 1876 · 24 players
A defunct franchise with no continuous modern successor. Its players are attributed here to New York Mutuals itself — never folded into an unrelated modern club, which would fabricate a lineage that never existed. See the full index of lost clubs.
Mount Rushmore
The four largest measured careers at this club, by StatVault VAL attributed to New York Mutuals itself. A season counts here only when New York Mutuals is the one club whose recorded span covers it — 1 contested season is credited to nobody rather than double-counted. 9 of 24 players on this roster carry a measurable VAL.
- 1876 · P6.5
- 1876 · SS5.8
- 1876 · 1B3.2
- 1876 · CF2.5
Club Leaders · top 9
| # | Player | Years | Club VAL |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bobby Mathews | 1876 | 6.5 |
| 2 | Jimmy Hallinan | 1876 | 5.8 |
| 3 | Joe Start | 1876 | 3.2 |
| 4 | Fred Treacey | 1876 | 2.5 |
| 5 | Jim Holdsworth | 1876 | 2.5 |
| 6 | Bill Craver | 1876 | 2.2 |
| 7 | Nat Hicks | 1876 | 1.8 |
| 8 | Eddie Booth | 1876 | 1.3 |
| 9 | Al Nichols | 1876 | 1.1 |
Full Roster (24)
| Player | Pos | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Al Nichols | 3B | 1876 |
| Bill Craver | 2B | 1876 |
| Billy West | 2B | 1876 |
| Bob Valentine | C | 1876 |
| Bobby Mathews | P | 1876 |
| Davy Force | SS | 1876 |
| Eddie Booth | RF | 1876 |
| Fred Treacey | CF | 1876 |
| George Bechtel | RF | 1876 |
| George Fair | 2B | 1876 |
| George Heubel | RF | 1876 |
| George Seward | OF | 1876 |
| Jim Holdsworth | CF | 1876 |
| Jim Shandley | OF | 1876 |
| Jimmy Hallinan | SS | 1876 |
| Joe Start | 1B | 1876 |
| John Hatfield | LF | 1876 |
| John Hayes | LF | 1876 |
| John Maloney | CF | 1876 |
| John McGuinness | 1B | 1876 |
| Nat Hicks | C | 1876 |
| Nealy Phelps | RF | 1876 |
| Pete Treacey | SS | 1876 |
| Terry Larkin | P | 1876 |