StatVault

19th-Century Majors

New York Mutuals

Active 1876 · 24 players

A defunct franchise with no continuous modern successor. Its players are attributed here to New York Mutuals itself — never folded into an unrelated modern club, which would fabricate a lineage that never existed. See the full index of lost clubs.

Mount Rushmore

The four largest measured careers at this club, by StatVault VAL attributed to New York Mutuals itself. A season counts here only when New York Mutuals is the one club whose recorded span covers it — 1 contested season is credited to nobody rather than double-counted. 4 of 24 players on this roster carry a measurable VAL.

  1. 1Jimmy Hallinan
    1876 · SS2.3
  2. 2Joe Start
    1876 · 1B0.6
  3. 3Nat Hicks
    1876 · C0.4
  4. 4Bobby Mathews
    1876 · P0.2

Full Roster (24)

PlayerPosYears
Al Nichols3B1876
Bill Craver2B1876
Billy West2B1876
Bob ValentineC1876
Bobby MathewsP1876
Davy ForceSS1876
Eddie BoothRF1876
Fred TreaceyCF1876
George BechtelRF1876
George Fair2B1876
George HeubelRF1876
George SewardOF1876
Jim HoldsworthCF1876
Jim ShandleyOF1876
Jimmy HallinanSS1876
Joe Start1B1876
John HatfieldLF1876
John HayesLF1876
John MaloneyCF1876
John McGuinness1B1876
Nat HicksC1876
Nealy PhelpsRF1876
Pete TreaceySS1876
Terry LarkinP1876