Season Almanac
| Team | Record | Roster VAL | Top player | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Philadelphia Athletics | 66-32 | 59 | Bobby Mathews | |
| St. Louis Cardinals | 65-33 | 67.7 | Tony Mullane | |
| Atlanta Braves | 63-35 | 105 | Jim Whitney | |
| Cincinnati Red Stockings | 61-37 | 77.4 | Will White | |
| Chicago Cubs | 59-39 | 101.8 | Larry Corcoran | |
| Providence Grays | 58-39 | 85.5 | Old Hoss Radbourn | |
| Cleveland Spiders | 55-42 | 67.4 | Jim McCormick | |
| New York Metropolitans | 54-42 | 51.3 | Tim Keefe | |
| Buffalo Bisons | 52-45 | 94.3 | Pud Galvin | |
| Louisville Colonels | 52-45 | 41.8 | Guy Hecker | |
| San Francisco Giants | 46-50 | 66.2 | John Ward | |
| Detroit Wolverines | 40-58 | 41.3 | Charlie Bennett | |
| Columbus Colts | 32-65 | 31.4 | Pop Smith | |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | 31-67 | 44.4 | Billy Taylor | |
| Baltimore Orioles | 28-68 | 27 | Jim Clinton | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | 16-80 | 21.2 | Emil Gross |
Record basis: summed pitcher wins and losses.