StatVault

All 32 franchises · all eras

Franchise Mt. Rushmores

The four greatest players in each franchise's entire history. Ranked by a franchise-legacy score — the data-calibrated HOF Monitor weighted by the share of a player's career spent with the team, so a franchise-defining career outranks a late-career rental. Honors-driven, so pre-1999 legends stand beside today's stars.

Buffalo BillsAFC East
  1. 1
    Bruce Smith
    DE1985–199915 yrs★ HOF
    135.9
  2. 2
    Thurman Thomas
    RB1988–199912 yrs★ HOF
    96.2
  3. 3
    Andre Reed
    WR1985–199915 yrs★ HOF
    69
  4. 4
    Jim Kelly
    QB1986–199611 yrs★ HOF
    63.8
Miami DolphinsAFC East
  1. 1
    Dan Marino
    QB1983–199917 yrs★ HOF
    155.8
  2. 2
    Zach Thomas
    ILB1996–200712 yrs★ HOF
    135
  3. 3
    Jason Taylor
    OLB1997–201113 yrs★ HOF
    114.1
  4. 4
    Tyreek Hill
    WR2022–20254 yrs
    81.8
New England PatriotsAFC East
  1. 1
    Tom Brady
    QB2001–201918 yrs
    187.2
  2. 2
    Rob Gronkowski
    TE2010–20189 yrs
    119.5
  3. 3
    Ben Coates
    TE1991–19999 yrs
    85.2
  4. 4
    Ty Law
    CB1995–200410 yrs★ HOF
    80.9
New York JetsAFC East
  1. 1
    Kevin Mawae
    C20031 yr★ HOF
    82.5
  2. 2
    Curtis Martin
    RB1998–20058 yrs★ HOF
    72.3
  3. 3
    Freeman McNeil
    RB1981–199212 yrs
    69.4
  4. 4
    Darrelle Revis
    DB2007–20167 yrs★ HOF
    69
Baltimore RavensAFC North
  1. 1
    Ray Lewis
    ILB1996–201217 yrs★ HOF
    172.4
  2. 2
    Ed Reed
    FS2002–201211 yrs★ HOF
    149
  3. 3
    Jonathan Ogden
    OT19961 yr★ HOF
    99
  4. 4
    Terrell Suggs
    OLB2003–201815 yrs
    98.1
Cincinnati BengalsAFC North
  1. 1
    Anthony Munoz
    OT1980–19886 yrs★ HOF
    159
  2. 2
    Geno Atkins
    DT2010–202011 yrs
    98.8
  3. 3
    Chad Johnson
    WR2001–201010 yrs
    86.2
  4. 4
    Ja'Marr Chase
    WR2021–20255 yrs
    80
Cleveland BrownsAFC North
  1. 1
    Myles Garrett
    DE2017–20259 yrs
    150.1
  2. 2
    Jim Brown
    FB1957–19659 yrs★ HOF
    97.7
  3. 3
    Nick Chubb
    RB2018–20246 yrs
    48.3
  4. 4
    Ozzie Newsome
    TE1978–199013 yrs★ HOF
    46.6
Pittsburgh SteelersAFC North
  1. 1
    T.J. Watt
    OLB2017–20259 yrs
    146.6
  2. 2
    Rod Woodson
    FS1987–19969 yrs★ HOF
    129.2
  3. 3
    Antonio Brown
    WR2010–20189 yrs
    125.2
  4. 4
    Cameron Heyward
    DE2011–202515 yrs
    123.6
Houston TexansAFC South
  1. 1
    J.J. Watt
    DE2011–20209 yrs
    129
  2. 2
    Andre Johnson
    WR2003–201412 yrs★ HOF
    100.6
  3. 3
    DeAndre Hopkins
    WR2013–20197 yrs
    75.3
  4. 4
    Derek Stingley Jr.
    CB2022–20254 yrs
    70.1
Indianapolis ColtsAFC South
  1. 1
    Peyton Manning
    QB1998–201013 yrs★ HOF
    197.5
  2. 2
    Marvin Harrison
    WR1996–200813 yrs★ HOF
    144
  3. 3
    Dwight Freeney
    DE2002–201211 yrs★ HOF
    108.7
  4. 4
    Eric Dickerson
    RB1987–19915 yrs★ HOF
    105.6
Jacksonville JaguarsAFC South
  1. 1
    Jimmy Smith
    WR1995–200511 yrs
    65.8
  2. 2
    Jalen Ramsey
    CB2016–20183 yrs
    52.3
  3. 3
    Maurice Jones-Drew
    RB2006–20138 yrs
    52
  4. 4
    Josh Hines-Allen
    DE2019–20257 yrs
    48.6
Tennessee TitansAFC South
  1. 1
    Derrick Henry
    RB2016–20238 yrs
    91.4
  2. 2
    Kevin Byard
    FS2016–20227 yrs
    83.8
  3. 3
    Eddie George
    RB1996–20038 yrs
    69.8
  4. 4
    Jeffery Simmons
    DT2019–20257 yrs
    60.6
Denver BroncosAFC West
  1. 1
    Shannon Sharpe
    TE1990–200312 yrs★ HOF
    121.6
  2. 2
    Peyton Manning
    QB2012–20154 yrs★ HOF
    109.6
  3. 3
    Terrell Davis
    RB1995–20017 yrs★ HOF
    107.1
  4. 4
    Champ Bailey
    CB2004–201310 yrs★ HOF
    105.6
Kansas City ChiefsAFC West
  1. 1
    Tony Gonzalez
    TE1997–200812 yrs★ HOF
    170.3
  2. 2
    Travis Kelce
    TE2014–202512 yrs
    151.1
  3. 3
    Derrick Thomas
    OLB1989–199911 yrs★ HOF
    117.1
  4. 4
    Tyreek Hill
    WR2016–20216 yrs
    100.2
Las Vegas RaidersAFC West
  1. 1
    Jerry Rice
    WR2001–20033 yrs★ HOF
    124.4
  2. 2
    Charles Woodson
    FS1998–201511 yrs★ HOF
    102.1
  3. 3
    Shane Lechler
    P2000–201213 yrs
    79
  4. 4
    Khalil Mack
    OLB2014–20174 yrs
    71.4
Los Angeles ChargersAFC West
  1. 1
    LaDainian Tomlinson
    RB2001–20099 yrs★ HOF
    124.7
  2. 2
    Junior Seau
    LB1990–200213 yrs★ HOF
    116.7
  3. 3
    Drew Brees
    QB2002–20054 yrs★ HOF
    77.5
  4. 4
    Philip Rivers
    QB2006–201914 yrs
    74
Dallas CowboysNFC East
  1. 1
    Emmitt Smith
    RB1990–200213 yrs★ HOF
    182.1
  2. 2
    DeMarcus Ware
    OLB2005–20139 yrs★ HOF
    130
  3. 3
    Jason Witten
    TE2003–201916 yrs
    125
  4. 4
    Larry Allen
    G20031 yr★ HOF
    124.5
New York GiantsNFC East
  1. 1
    Michael Strahan
    DE1993–200715 yrs★ HOF
    144.1
  2. 2
    Mark Bavaro
    TE1985–19906 yrs
    68.7
  3. 3
    Trent Williams
    OT20131 yr
    66.8
  4. 4
    Osi Umenyiora
    DE2003–20129 yrs
    63
Philadelphia EaglesNFC East
  1. 1
    Brian Dawkins
    S1996–200813 yrs★ HOF
    102.4
  2. 2
    Mike Quick
    WR1982–19909 yrs
    81.6
  3. 3
    Fletcher Cox
    DT2012–202312 yrs
    74.9
  4. 4
    LeSean McCoy
    RB2009–20146 yrs
    69.4
Washington CommandersNFC East
  1. 1
    Champ Bailey
    CB1999–20035 yrs★ HOF
    74.7
  2. 2
    Art Monk
    WR1980–199314 yrs★ HOF
    74.1
  3. 3
    Bruce Smith
    DE2000–20034 yrs★ HOF
    70.2
  4. 4
    Darrell Green
    CB1983–200220 yrs★ HOF
    67.3
Chicago BearsNFC North
  1. 1
    Brian Urlacher
    MLB2000–201212 yrs★ HOF
    118.5
  2. 2
    Khalil Mack
    OLB2018–20214 yrs
    71.4
  3. 3
    Julius Peppers
    DE2010–20134 yrs★ HOF
    68.2
  4. 4
    Sid Luckman
    QB1939–19509 yrs★ HOF
    68
Detroit LionsNFC North
  1. 1
    Barry Sanders
    RB1989–199810 yrs★ HOF
    200.1
  2. 2
    Calvin Johnson
    WR2007–20159 yrs★ HOF
    122.9
  3. 3
    Herman Moore
    WR1991–200010 yrs
    94.8
  4. 4
    Matthew Stafford
    QB2009–202012 yrs
    71.5
Green Bay PackersNFC North
  1. 1
    Don Hutson
    TE1935–194511 yrs★ HOF
    180.7
  2. 2
    Brett Favre
    QB1992–200716 yrs★ HOF
    143.5
  3. 3
    Aaron Rodgers
    QB2008–202215 yrs
    132.8
  4. 4
    Sterling Sharpe
    WR1988–19947 yrs★ HOF
    115.9
Minnesota VikingsNFC North
  1. 1
    Randall McDaniel
    G19961 yr★ HOF
    141
  2. 2
    Adrian Peterson
    RB2007–20158 yrs
    116.3
  3. 3
    Randy Moss
    WR1998–20047 yrs★ HOF
    107
  4. 4
    Chris Doleman
    DE1985–199910 yrs★ HOF
    97.7
Atlanta FalconsNFC South
  1. 1
    Tony Gonzalez
    TE2009–20135 yrs★ HOF
    109.9
  2. 2
    Julio Jones
    WR2011–202010 yrs
    94.7
  3. 3
    Deion Sanders
    CB1989–19935 yrs★ HOF
    84.4
  4. 4
    Matt Ryan
    QB2008–202114 yrs
    73.3
Carolina PanthersNFC South
  1. 1
    Luke Kuechly
    ILB2012–20198 yrs★ HOF
    127.6
  2. 2
    Kevin Greene
    OLB19991 yr★ HOF
    116.1
  3. 3
    Julius Peppers
    DE2002–201810 yrs★ HOF
    107.8
  4. 4
    Christian McCaffrey
    RB2017–20214 yrs
    59.2
New Orleans SaintsNFC South
  1. 1
    Drew Brees
    QB2006–202015 yrs★ HOF
    150
  2. 2
    Cameron Jordan
    DE2011–202515 yrs
    102.6
  3. 3
    Michael Thomas
    WR2016–20236 yrs
    77.9
  4. 4
    Jimmy Graham
    TE2010–20236 yrs
    58.4
Tampa Bay BuccaneersNFC South
  1. 1
    Derrick Brooks
    OLB1995–200814 yrs★ HOF
    117.2
  2. 2
    Warren Sapp
    DT1995–20039 yrs★ HOF
    107
  3. 3
    John Lynch
    FS1993–200311 yrs★ HOF
    104.6
  4. 4
    Ronde Barber
    FS1998–201215 yrs★ HOF
    101.6
Arizona CardinalsNFC West
  1. 1
    Larry Fitzgerald
    WR2004–202017 yrs★ HOF
    120
  2. 2
    Patrick Peterson
    CB2011–202010 yrs
    95.2
  3. 3
    Aeneas Williams
    FS1994–20007 yrs★ HOF
    93.2
  4. 4
    Chandler Jones
    DE2016–20216 yrs
    74.7
Los Angeles RamsNFC West
  1. 1
    Aaron Donald
    DL2014–202310 yrs
    146
  2. 2
    Eric Dickerson
    RB1983–19926 yrs★ HOF
    115.7
  3. 3
    Marshall Faulk
    RB1999–20057 yrs★ HOF
    91.9
  4. 4
    Torry Holt
    WR1999–200810 yrs
    87.1
San Francisco 49ersNFC West
  1. 1
    Jerry Rice
    WR1985–200015 yrs★ HOF
    278.2
  2. 2
    Patrick Willis
    ILB2007–20148 yrs★ HOF
    122.8
  3. 3
    Terrell Owens
    WR1996–20038 yrs★ HOF
    118.5
  4. 4
    George Kittle
    TE2017–20259 yrs
    97.3
Seattle SeahawksNFC West
  1. 1
    Bobby Wagner
    MLB2012–202311 yrs
    143.5
  2. 2
    Cortez Kennedy
    DT1990–200011 yrs★ HOF
    96.1
  3. 3
    Earl Thomas
    FS2010–20189 yrs
    93.3
  4. 4
    Richard Sherman
    CB2011–20177 yrs
    84.6

Built Jul 15, 2026 · legacy score = HOF Monitor × √(career share). Coverage follows the encyclopedia — a few pre-merger legends without a full statistical profile may not yet appear.